· International edition
POTATOES.NEWSGlobal potato industry intelligence
Watch Potatoes.News
In focusInternational Potato Tour Heads to YUGAGRO 2026: Let’s Meet in Krasnodar ↗
Europe

Irish High Court Rules Potato and Onion Storage Buildings Subject to Commercial Rates; Macra Warns of Cost Impact

Potatoes stored in a wooden crate. Photo: Kindel Media (Pexels) Ireland's High Court has ruled that potato and onion storage buildings are liable for commercial rates, in a case involving Castlecor Potato Company and Tailte Éireann —…

Irish High Court Rules Potato and Onion Storage Buildings Subject to Commercial Rates; Macra Warns of Cost ImpactPotatoes.News
Potatoes stored in a wooden crate. Photo: Kindel Media (Pexels)

Ireland’s High Court has ruled that potato and onion storage buildings are liable for commercial rates, in a case involving Castlecor Potato Company and Tailte Éireann — a decision with potential reach well beyond the two crops named in the dispute. Farm organization Macra warns the precedent could raise operating costs for growers and chill investment in storage infrastructure across Ireland.

Irish agricultural organization Macra has raised concerns following a High Court ruling that makes potato and onion storage buildings liable for commercial rates. The case, involving Castlecor Potato Company and Tailte Éireann, could have implications for other agricultural and horticultural storage facilities across Ireland.

Storage as “processing”? Macra argues that buildings used to store harvested crops and agricultural inputs should remain exempt from commercial rates under the Valuation Act, and that such buildings have traditionally been treated that way. The organization warns that extending rates to these facilities could increase operating costs for growers and affect investment in farm infrastructure. Macra president Josephine O’Neill said storage facilities are essential to the day-to-day operation of a farm and should not be classified as commercial premises — the distinction at the heart of the case.

Morning industry digest The day’s essentials in one email.

Weekdays. Unsubscribe in one click.

“It is madness to me that the storage of potatoes and onions could be described as an act of processing,” O’Neill said. “The issue of the potatoes and onions not being produced on lands attached to the buildings” is, in her view, “a bizarre conclusion to come to.” The quotes capture the industry’s core frustration: that a passive activity — keeping a harvested crop in a shed — is being treated as if it were a commercial transformation of the product.

A classification problem with wide reach. According to Macra, the ruling raises questions about how agricultural storage activities are classified for rates purposes, particularly when crops are grown on land separate from the storage facilities — a common arrangement in Irish potato production, where centralized stores serve multiple contracted fields. If the commercial-rates logic holds, any specialized storage building not sitting directly on the growing land could become rateable, with obvious consequences for consolidation of the storage sector. Macra also warns that added storage costs could discourage investment and add pressure to farm viability and food security more broadly.

Appeal sought. Macra wants the decision overturned on appeal if the case proceeds to the Supreme Court. The organization’s position is that the Valuation Act was written to protect exactly this kind of farm infrastructure, and that the High Court’s interpretation stretches the concept of “processing” beyond anything legislators intended. It remains unclear from available reporting whether an appeal has formally been lodged.

The dispute lands at a sensitive moment for Ireland’s potato and onion sectors: storage quality has become a competitive factor as retail specifications tighten, and adding a recurring rates bill to the fixed costs of modern stores could discourage exactly the investment the industry is being asked to make. Whether the Supreme Court takes the case will determine if the High Court’s reading of “processing” becomes settled law — or a one-off that the Valuation Act quietly absorbs. Until then, growers and co-ops planning new stores face an unwelcome uncertainty premium.

Sources: FreshPlaza; Farmers Journal (Ireland).

Published report and original attribution: Potatoes.News ↗

Search

Languages

Only reviewed translations are published. Unavailable pages open in English.

Video

📰 My digest — pick topics and read offline